The holiday season is a time of joy, togetherness, and giving — and our pets are no exception when it comes to being part of the celebration. Whether your dog is the kind that eagerly tears into gift wrap or your cat prefers to nap in an empty gift box, they deserve a little something special. But pampering your furry friend doesn’t mean you have to empty your wallet.

In this budget-friendly holiday gift guide, we’ve rounded up affordable, delightful treats and toys that your pets will absolutely love — and so will your bank account.

Why Gifts Matter for Pets

Pets might not understand the holidays, but they absolutely feel the excitement. New toys and treats provide much-needed stimulation, strengthen your bond, and add to their overall well-being. Plus, watching them enjoy their presents is one of the purest joys of the season!

Budget-Friendly Pet Gift Ideas

Here’s a curated list of affordable treats and toys for dogs, cats, and even small pets like rabbits and guinea pigs — all under $25.

1. DIY Treat Jars – Personalized and Practical

A glass jar filled with your pet’s favorite snacks makes a heartfelt and inexpensive gift. Decorate it with their name and a festive bow.

Estimated Cost: $5–$10

DIY Option:
Make your own healthy dog biscuits or catnip treats with ingredients you already have at home. There are dozens of easy online recipes using items like oats, pumpkin, peanut butter (xylitol-free), or tuna.

2. Plush Toys – Soft Companions for Snuggling and Play

For dogs that love cuddling or carrying around a buddy, soft plush toys are a win. Many pet stores offer multi-packs for $10–$15. Look for squeakers or crinkly materials for added excitement.

Tip for Small Dogs or Cats:
Baby toys from discount stores (without small, detachable parts) can be a surprisingly affordable option.

Average Cost: $5–$10

3. Interactive Puzzle Toys – Brain Boosters on a Budget

These toys engage your pet’s mind, making them work for their food or treats. Great for reducing boredom and anxiety, especially when guests are over during the holidays.

Budget Options:

  • Slide puzzle treat toys for dogs and cats
  • Snuffle mats (you can DIY one with fleece strips)
  • Egg carton puzzle (yes, even free if you DIY)

Estimated Cost: $0–$20

4. Catnip Toys – Budget Fun for Your Feline

Catnip toys are a guaranteed hit for most cats. Whether it’s a fish, mouse, or banana-shaped plush, these toys are fun to pounce, chew, and bat around.

DIY Tip:
Sew your own from felt or cotton, fill with catnip, and stitch closed — a few cents per toy!

Store Price: $2–$8

5. Chew Toys – Long-Lasting & Entertaining

Perfect for dogs who love to chew (and protect your furniture in the process), these toys come in many shapes and sizes.

Look For:

  • Durable rubber bones
  • Nylon chew rings
  • Rope toys (also good for tug-of-war)

Average Cost: $5–$15

Bonus: Many are flavored or hollowed for stuffing with peanut butter.

6. Treat Dispensers – Delicious Distractions

KONG-style treat dispensers are fantastic for mental stimulation. Fill them with peanut butter, yogurt, or freeze-dried treats.

DIY Idea:
Stuff a paper towel roll with kibble and twist the ends. Simple, effective, and free!

Retail Cost: $7–$15

7. Holiday-Themed Collars & Bandanas

Dress your pet in festive style with a holiday bandana or bowtie. It’s the perfect touch for holiday photos or family gatherings.

DIY Tip:
Use scrap fabric to sew your own or repurpose an old holiday scarf.

Store Price: $3–$10

8. Tunnels & Huts for Small Pets

Rabbits, guinea pigs, and ferrets love cozy places to hide and play. Fabric tunnels and small fleece huts offer enrichment without high costs.

Affordable Picks:

  • Pop-up play tunnels ($10–$15)
  • Cardboard castles (build your own for free!)
  • Fleece sleeping sacks

Cost Range: $0–$20

9. Squeaky Balls & Fetch Toys

Dogs with high energy levels love toys that keep them moving. Tennis balls, frisbees, or soft fetch toys are affordable classics.

Money-Saving Idea:
Buy multi-packs for better value, often 3–5 toys for $10.

Price Range: $3–$15

10. Stocking Stuffers for Pets

Yes, your pet can have a stocking too! Here are some inexpensive fillers:

  • Dehydrated treat bags ($5–$8)
  • Cat teaser wands ($2–$5)
  • Tiny plushies
  • Mini grooming tools
  • Dental chews

Hang it beside the family’s stockings and let them sniff it out on Christmas morning.

Holiday Safety Tips for Pet Gifts

While shopping or crafting for your pet, always keep safety top of mind:

  • Avoid toxic ingredients in treats (no chocolate, xylitol, onions, grapes, etc.)
  • Supervise play with new toys to ensure your pet doesn’t chew off and swallow small parts.
  • Choose the right size toy for your pet’s breed.
  • Check materials for choking hazards or allergens.

Where to Shop for Affordable Pet Gifts

  • Dollar Stores: Stock up on basic toys and accessories for under $5.
  • Online Marketplaces: Sites like Chewy, Amazon, and Etsy often run holiday sales.
  • Local Shelters: Some shelters sell handmade pet toys to fundraise — a great way to give back.
  • Thrift Stores: Look for clean baby toys, baskets, and fabric to repurpose.

Make It Special: Gift Wrapping for Pets

Yes, pets enjoy the unwrapping process! Use tissue paper, small boxes, or fabric wraps. Be sure to avoid ribbons, glitter, or bows that might be eaten. The crinkling sound adds to the excitement for cats and dogs alike.

Fun Idea:
Create a scavenger hunt by hiding a few wrapped gifts around the house!

Gifts That Keep Giving

Looking for meaningful gifts that benefit more than just your pet?

  • Adopt or foster a pet from a shelter — a life-changing holiday gift.
  • Donate to an animal rescue in your pet’s name.
  • Sponsor a pet through programs that allow monthly contributions.

These gifts make the world a little brighter for animals in need.

Final Thoughts

You don’t need to spend a fortune to show your pets how much you love them this holiday season. With a little creativity and intention, you can find or create the perfect gifts that bring joy, comfort, and enrichment to your furry family member — all without busting your holiday budget.

Whether it’s a handmade treat, a squeaky toy, or a cozy bed near the fire, your pet will appreciate the extra love. After all, isn’t that what the holidays are all about?

Happy Howl-idays and Meowy Christmas to you and your four-legged friends!